Showing posts with label fraud. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fraud. Show all posts

Thursday, March 6, 2014

The High Price of Keeping Up Appearances


The not-entirely-surprising news that leaders of a certain bankrupt big-name law firm have been indicted (Matthew Goldstein, Former Top Leaders of Dewey & LeBoeuf Are Indicted, New York Times DealB%k, Mar. 6, 2014) is a cogent reminder that law firms in trouble don’t exactly confess to it. They may indeed go to unfathomable lengths to maintain an air of business-as-usual even as that very business is going down the drain. Really, who wouldn’t have doubts about a firm that couldn’t even manage itself?

Be aware that a troubled employer probably won’t disclose its real status. How many of us have heard about firms that still send recruiters to law schools even though they know no offers will be made? Is a firm having difficulty paying its legal research database bills? Have its copiers just been repossessed? Has the firm abruptly stopped providing certain benefits? Note the details. Talk to people.

Need to learn more about an enterprise?  Try chatting someone up in the restroom.
Prospective new hires need to remember to undertake as much due diligence as they can before signing on to any firm. What can be learned about a firm’s fortunes? Pay attention to appearances. How run down is the place? What do the back rooms look like? How current is equipment?

Try to chat up as many prospective colleagues as you can. To this day, some of my own best reconnaissance has occurred in the lavatory. It can be amazing whom you might strike up a conversation with while you’re applying more lip gloss in the ladies room. It can be even more amazing what a stranger in the bathroom might actually tell you.

See also Lori Tripoli, Don’t Be the One Laid Off: Check your Employer’s Background First, ContemporaryLawOfficeManagement, June 24, 2013.

—Lori Tripoli

Thursday, March 28, 2013

A Few Good Things about that “Churn, Baby, Churn” Firm


If I were queen at megafirm DLA Piper, I’m not sure I would boast about a film about fraudulent conduct made in-house on my home page, especially if it were titled At What Cost? But I don’t work at DLA Piper, let alone run the place, so I can’t really account for the firm’s tin ear here. Pundits are already wondering why the firm would ever pursue $700 grand in unpaid legal bills from a bankrupt client when there were damning emails in its own ether stating—explicitly—that the firm was in “standard ‘churn that bill,’ baby!” mode.  


Observers can’t help but be curious about why the firm would move forward in that pursuit even after the firm had been disqualified from representing the corporate client in its bankruptcy action thanks to a conflict of interest. That the firm would think that now’s a super-great time to mention that it won an award for making a training video about corruption involving management called At What Cost? is just beyond the beyond.

But let’s not pile on DLA Piper’s very bad week. A few good things about what is no doubt a basically very capable firm have emerged from the mess:

  • Maybe no one really noticed that bit about the firm churning bills since it’s spring break/Easter week/Passover.
  • The oft-boasted-about “firm collegiality” actually seems to exist at DLA Piper as evidenced by the string of emails from various lawyers supporting the churning guy (Hence, “Yeah Team Tim!”) and email rounds planning an outing after the firm ‘withdrew’ because of its conflict of interest (“Well,the Judge just fired us . . . . Drinks anyone?”).
  • The training video looks like it might be pretty good. The teaser is on Youtube. Take a look! You might even leave a comment. Maybe DLA Piper will just dismiss it as another “inexcusable effort at humor.”
Even if DLA Piper recovers its fees, ya just gotta wonder, at what cost?

—Lori Tripoli
 

Thursday, September 6, 2012

How Many Bad Lawyers Are There?

It’s around this time of year—when I am paying bar dues—that I always think about client protection funds used to reimburse clients who have been defrauded by lawyers. I always wonder—how many really bad lawyers are out there? What is the intake versus the outgo from these funds? Who are the most likely recipients of money from a client protection fund? What are the funds’ administration costs?

Apparently, others in the legal field have pondered these very issues. ABA Model Rule for Lawyers’ Funds for Client Protection Rule 7 requires client protection funds to provide annual reports to the court and to invest unused portions. A 2010 survey by the Standing Committee on Client Protection of the American Bar Association found that fund administrators in jurisdictions with high numbers of lawyers (more than 40,000) earn a little more than $100,000 annually; those in small jurisdictions (less than 15,000) earn, on average, $71,000.

Another ABA report, 2008-2010 Survey of Lawyers’ Funds for Client Protection, indicates that in 2010, the jurisdiction where I am admitted—Maryland—had a little over $700,000 in revenues from attorney assessments. New York, where I live, had almost $7.5 million. Eighty-one claims were approved in Maryland in that year; 198 in New York. In Maryland, claims for a little more than $1.7 million all told were approved in 2010; in New York, that figure was $8.5 million. There were around 35,000 lawyers admitted in Maryland at the time the report was prepared; there were more than 262,000 in New York.

I’m curious about what client protection fund income and outgo will be for the next couple of years as the legal industry continues to experience a tumultuous economy and a market that is evolving quickly. Will client protection fund revenues decrease and claims spike? Could that be because there are more bad lawyers, or a few lawyers doing worse and more expensive things? Or will they all just stop sinning?

Lawyers—and clients—might just do a bit of researching about client protection funds in their own jurisdictions; lawyers to see where their assessments go, and clients to understand the protections afforded them.